Category: PTO Director Review of AIA Trials
-
Institution Discretion and the 2026 AIA Docket
—
by
in America Invents Act, Ex Parte Prosecution, Federal Circuit Review of PTAB Proceedings, Future of PTAB Trial Practice, inter partes review, Litigation, Mandamus Actions in the Federal Circuit, Patent Portfolio Management, petitions practice, Post Grant Review, Prosecution Guidelines, PTAB, PTAB Patent Trials, PTO Director Review of AIA Trials, reexamination generally, serial petitionsSept. 2, 2026 Last September, after John Squires was confirmed as Director, I wrote that we would see whether the then-emerging line of discretionary dismissals of IPR petitions “is to be extended or will itself be tempered.” The Federal Circuit answered the reviewability half on November 6. The 2026 filing and institution numbers supply the…
-
Federal Circuit Denies Mandamus in Three IPR Institution Challenges: Deference to PTAB Discretion
—
by
in Amended Rulemaking, America Invents Act, claim challenges, Federal Circuit, Federal Circuit Review of PTAB Proceedings, Future of PTAB Trial Practice, IPR, Litigation, Mandamus Actions in the Federal Circuit, Post Grant Review, PTAB, PTAB Patent Trials, PTO Director Review of AIA Trials, PTO Sued Under the APANov. 6, 2025 In three nonprecedential orders issued today, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit denied mandamus relief for petitioners challenging the Patent Trial and Appeal Board’s (PTAB) discretionary denials of inter partes review (IPR) petitions. These decisions—arising from parallel district court litigation and the recent rescission of interim guidance on IPR…
-
Petitioners Target PTAB’s Discretionary Denials with Federal Circuit Mandamus Petitions
In a series of recent filings before the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit, petitioners including Motorola Solutions, Inc., SAP America, Inc., Google LLC, Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd., SanDisk Technologies, Inc., Western Digital Technologies, Inc., and HighLevel, Inc. are pressing for writs of mandamus to overturn PTAB denials of inter partes review (IPR)…
-
PTAB Discretionary Denials and Patent Prosecution Topics at the 2025 Midwest IP Institute
Join us at the 2025 Midwest IP Institute on September 18 and 19 for a deep dive into patent, trademark, and copyright topics. On Friday, September 19, I’ll be moderating a special panel discussing recent PTO developments that impact patent practice. We’ll explore PTAB discretionary denials, the new prior art fee structure, and their influence…